Best 3 Star Hotels In Fire Island 2025

There’s a reason 3-star AARP hotels in Fire Island are so incredibly popular. They combine comforting amenities and just-for-you service with some of the best rates and discounts around. And here at AARP Travel Center Powered by Expedia, we understand just what you’re looking for during your travels. We know perks like on-site restaurants and cocktail bars, pool access, and spacious rooms at 3-star economy AARP hotels in Fire Island, New York are certain to bring your post-retirement getaway from drab to fab without draining your savings.

Expedia and AARP have teamed up to present you with the some of the best rates around on three-star hotels for AARP members and seniors in Fire Island. We’re dedicated to providing you with the most inviting accommodations for your visits to see family and your monumental wedding anniversaries. Browse our Fire Island hotels with 3-stars for AARP members, where you’ll find cheap rates without compromising comfort and style.