Save on Car Rentals in Fire Island for 2026

Rental Car Guide in Fire Island

Once you've finally arrived in Fire Island, the one thing you don't want to do is waste more effort worrying about public transit or carrying your bags on foot. Supply yourself with a sense of liberty by renting a car and erasing your dependence on streetcar timetables, stop locations, or cab availability and allows you to immediately get to doing what you came here for: the sites, sounds, and flavors of the city. Make your vacation more relaxing and rent a car every time you're in Fire Island. With AARP Expedia Travel, you can book with some of the best car rental agencies in Fire Island and get the vehicle you want at a fantastic discount rate.

Discover Fire Island

You're going to be glad you booked a rental car while traveling to Fire Island. With four golf courses less than 10 miles away, you may want to upgrade to a full-size or SUV to store your golf clubs. Grab your best driver and hit up courses like West Sayville Golf Course, Island Hills Golf Club, Bellport Country Club, and Timber Point Golf Course. However if golf isn't on your itinerary, then perhaps wine tasting is. Drive over to Adams County winery and see how this place stomps grapes to bring out their best.

It's easy to find your preferred vehicle. You can sort by:

• Price: We have rates starting as low as $120
• Supplier: Choose from around suppliers like Enterprise, Hertz, and more
• Car type: Choose a hybrid for the best in Mpg and price or kick the tires on a luxury ride to make your trip one you soon won't forget
• AARP Exclusives: Sort through some of our best members-only Fire Island rental car deals

Getting the rental car you want and saving money while doing it has never been easier.

Save on your Fire Island rental car

A car rental in Fire Island means you can visit the hot spots you're looking forward to most, without wasting effort waiting on streetcars and rideshares. Whether you want a convertible where you can lower the top and your inhibitions while on vacation, or you need something roomier like a SUV, you'll get a terrific deal on your Fire Island rental car when you go through the AARP Travel Center powered by Expedia®. With your AARP Membership, you can save up to 30% on selected car rentals, which means more money for you to spend on souvenirs, a nice dinner, or another vacation to Fire Island. Reserve your vehicle now and get ready to see Fire Island from the driver's seat.