Valley Cottage Vacations

This is a clean room but a very old hotel. Bed was very old air-conditioning was cool but very loud as it was a window unit.

Great location and staff!

The entire room and bathroom is small so it's a good option if you don't expect to stay in the hotel for long. The room has dings on the wall and the bathroom shower floor had stains that don't seem to get out. There were some areas that seem like they normally aren't cleaned. The breakfast was good with a decent variety of food. It does get pretty packed. The hotel is about 5 minutes from the subways and close enough to Times Square/ Broadway shows that there are always people walking around late at night. It's a good location if you want to be near Times Square and the surrounding areas and you won't expect to be in the hotel room for long.

Pros: Great location and a very friendly and helpful staff. Cons: The public spaces downstairs are public, noisy and always full of people. Sometimes it was even difficult to reach the room because of the crowd at the hotel's main entrance.

Clean and cool during summer - neighbors were smoking though

I travel to New York at least once a year on business and this hotel was a pleasant surprise. Located in the heart of Greeley Square, normally a hotel here you might find loud, run down and not particularly comfortable. It was nice and quiet despite the surrounding area, was clean and the beds were very comfortable. There is a modest complimentary breakfast served which was also nice before venturing out for the day.