Fire Island Vacation Packages for 2026

Oh boy where do I start, when I first checked in there were only four people in front of me, the four of us were wet from the storm ,but for some reason it took over 30 minutes to check in , was told the hot water did not work and it’s $100 per night which it did not say on the website and they don’t tell you until you get to the hotel so they were holding 300 dollars of my money and the AC was not working right, there’s no fan in the bathroom so it was pretty much humid in there. upon my stay, there were people slamming doors from the morning till after midnight., housekeepers were talking very loud in the morning, which is unprofessional. The rooms are below basic, overpriced, and dirty.

It was clean, the beds were comfortable. Absolutely loved the shower!

Property is right next to a club or bar and on a main street. It was very loud all night with music, people on the street , horns honking, and police. The room is very small, barely fits the bed but the bed was comfortable. In NY I expect smaller rooms so there is only so much to say about that but the noise from the are and street all night were too much. I would not be able to ever stay their again due to the noise. If you stay here plan on not sleeping. Good stuff to say. It had a great location in the city, the 7th floor roof access has a great view, the bed was comfortable, the water gets very hot but does have low pressure.

There were no amenities and the main entrance is closed. The room was very outdated and not very well maintained. There was mold in the bathroom and the a/c struggled to keep up. Also, if you weren't out of your room before 9am they wouldn't come back to clean the room. The Location was 5 star and the staff was very helpful other than the cleaning staff. Also, very convenient to Starbucks and Walgreens.

We loved our stay at the Gotham hotel. The rooms are clean and spacious and the staff were extremely friendly. The location is great and we would absolutely stay here again.