Shelter Island Rental Cars for AARP® Members

Photo by tom owens

Top Shelter Island Car Rental Deals

Don't see what you're looking for?

See all car rentals in Shelter Island
View all cars
Lowest prices found within the past 2 days. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Rental Car Guide in Shelter Island

You've spent all day trekking to your destination. If you're like most of us, you're ready to take a load off and actually get to the best part of any holiday—relaxing. You really don't want to consume more time sweating it out on foot or navigating confusing bus routes. Renting a car will help you get your stay started right now. No more waiting for your rideshare driver or navigating confusing subway lines. With the AARP Travel Center, you can grab the car or truck you want from the best car rental agencies at a fantastic discounted rate. Get on the road to freedom today!

Out and about in Shelter Island

You're going to be happy you rented a car while traveling to Shelter Island. When you want to really get away, this quaint area is the perfect spot. But with a bit of research, a dash of a curiosity, and your car rental, you may learn that this area has a lot to see and do. With four golf courses less than 10 miles away, you may want to upgrade to a full-size or SUV to store your golf clubs. Grab your best driver and hit up courses like Gardiners Bay Country Club, Shelter Island Country Club, Islands End Golf & Country Club Inc, and Sag Harbor Golf Club. But if golf isn't in your plans, then perhaps trying some local wine. Drive over to Adams County winery and learn how this winery squeezes grapes to bring out their best.

It's easy to find your preferred car. Sort rental cars by:

  • Price: We have prices starting as low as $388
  • Supplier: We work with some of the most trusted brands in the business, like Hertz and Enterprise. You can choose your vehicle from around suppliers.
  • Type: Pick from gas-sipping hybrids to SUVs that can haul everyone and everything. Choose the rental car that you want
  • AARP Member Exclusive: We have special, members-only rates on some the most popular vehicle types

In a few clicks you'll be well on your way to exploring Shelter Island.

Book your car rental

A car rental in Shelter Island lets you visit the things you came for. You can accelerate the fun during your vacation with a turn of the key and step on the gas pedal. Book your van through AARP Travel Center powered by Expedia® and you'll find the greatest discounts on the vehicle you desire, whether it's a pickup truck for yourself and a loved one or a minivan made to hold the whole family. With 30% off selected car rentals and no booking fees thanks to your AARP Membership, you'll have more money to play with when you're on vacation in Shelter Island. Reserve your vehicle now and enjoy Shelter Island on your own time.